According to “1619 Project” creator Nikole Hannah-Jones, “It will always be hard” for her to show any kind of patriotism towards America.
Hannah-Jones made her comments on Sunday during a forum at Howard University on democracy. The event, organized by Howard, the Pulitzer Center and Penguin Random House, also saw her dismiss the Declaration of Independence as “not” a liberty document.
Talking to Howard University constitutional law professor Lisa Crooms-Robinson, Hannah-Jones equivocated on a personal view of patriotism. At first, she stated, “This country would not be a democracy without us [Black people]. We would not have the freedoms that you have without Black people….So, yes, I believe in the patriotism that says we… force [America] to live up to its highest ideals.”
But then she added, “It’s hard for me, it will always be hard for me to claim any sort of patriotism. Just as a Black person who descends from slavery.”
Nikole Hannah-Jones speaks at Howard University’s "Democracy Summit" on November 15, 2022.
(Howard University )
The New York Times journalist’s 1619 Project, which rewrites America’s founding as based on slavery in 1619 and not liberty in 1776, has been taught in public schools across the country.
At the event, Hannah-Jones discussed how historians work, noting, “When historians or scholars are quoting a document, they are quoting the document that they find relevant to the argument they are going to make. But that’s not the whole document.”
After quizzing the audience on who has read all of the Declaration of Independence, she cited the famous clause in the second paragraph “that all men are created equal.”
Hannah-Jones claimed, “If you just read that, you think the Declaration of Independence is a liberty document. But it’s actually not. It’s a document of secession.” She continued, “It’s the colonists, the White colonists, laying out the crimes that they believe the British have committed against them.”
Conservatives, and critical historians, have generally argued that the 1619 Project distorted the true history of the U.S. with many of Nikole Hannah-Jones’ claims, but the mainstream media has largely turned a blind eye to negative feedback.
(AP Photo/John Minchillo)
The New York Times journalist added, “Part of what [the Declaration talks] about are the insurrections, which are the slave people. They say that the crown is stoking insurrection. So they’re stoking our enslaved people to rise up against them, which gives you a very different perspective on the Declaration of Independence reading in its entirety.”
During the talk, Hannah-Jones highlighted the groups of people who were not included as full citizens at the country’s founding. The way the 1619 Project founder looks at it, “It’s not until 1965, when we passed the Voting Rights Act… that we get a semblance of true democracy…. So, democracy in this country is really only 60 years old.”
"Declaration of Independence" – detail of the painting by John Trumbell. Undated color slide.
The Pulitzer Center, which describes itself on Twitter as “journalism and education for the public good,” sponsored the event.
